SCORING
Five ways to look at a plate.
Each score is a note on how I experienced one dish or meal on that day. Every category involves my own taste. Please read the numbers alongside the reasons in the article.
What the points mean
| Part | Score | Weight | What I notice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deliciousness | 1–5 | 40% | How much I enjoyed the taste, aroma, texture and finish. |
| Harmony | 1–5 | 20% | Whether temperature, cooking, texture and flavours felt pleasingly put together. |
| Character | 1–5 | 10% | How strongly the dish seemed to express something distinctive about that restaurant or dish, as I experienced it. |
| Worth the price | 1–5 | 10% | How I felt about what I received for the amount I paid. |
| Personal pull | 1–5 | 20% | How much the dish drew me in, whether or not I can fully explain why. |
Personal pull is where my own taste comes through.
I want to record not only how a dish tasted or came together, but also how much it appealed to me. Sometimes I can explain why; sometimes I cannot. Both belong in this part of the score.
How the numbers add up
The overall score is a weighted average, shown from 1 to 5. Each category contributes according to its weight: 40%, 20%, 10%, 10% and 20%. A 3 in every category gives an overall score of 3.0 out of 5. I do not rank different cuisines, prices or orders by score alone. Two meals with the same score may have entirely different strengths.